Will Private Practice bomb?

Kate Walsh Private Practice 1

The Boston Herald reviewed the new series, and I really hope they’re wrong.

If only your medical insurance covered the suffering of “Private Practice.”

The spinoff from ABC’s blockbuster “Grey’s Anatomy” (premiering Wednesday night at 9 on WCVB, Ch. 5) is practically dead on arrival, choked with contrived stories and lifeless characters.

As the show opens, OB-GYN specialist Addison (Kate Walsh) tenders her resignation to Seattle Grace, leaving (unseen) McDreamy and McSteamy for a ward of McStupids in Los Angeles.

At the medical co-op Oceanside Wellness Center, Addison learns to her horror that the rest of the staff doesn’t know she was hired.
“To them, I’m an interloper. I don’t lope,” she complains to best friend Dr. Naomi Bennett (Audra McDonald).

McDonald replaces Merrin Dungey as Addison’s best friend. It’s obvious why she was hired. Her character is far more neurotic, sobbing on the floor of the bathroom while stuffing her face with cake after the breakup of her marriage to Dr. Sam Bennett (Taye Diggs).

Addison’s new practice will consist, on average, of one patient a day, and that raises the first of many questions: How does this co-op pay for itself, anyway?

Naomi tries to explain. “It’s not about surgery. It’s about connecting.”

Addison bickers with holistic doc Pete Wilder (Tim Daly, who appears to have aged considerably since the first pilot was shot) over his methods and his kissing.

Amy Brenneman (“Judging Amy”) and Paul Edelstein (“Prison Break”) round out the cast as lovelorn doctors.

By the time Addison suffers a panic attack over a pregnant patient in crisis, you realize you are not watching the intimidating, competent Addison who made Seattle Grace interns quake. You are watching Meredith Grey as played by Kate Walsh. Creator Shonda Rhimes has merely swapped locations for one neurotic heroine.

As on “Grey’s,” there is the now trite device of a patient’s crisis somehow illuminating the physician’s personal life.

Wednesday night, Sam and Naomi learn an important after-school-special-worthy lesson in letting go from a wife and a mistress fighting over a dead man’s sperm. OK, a lesson from an after-school special on the Playboy Channel, but you get the drift.

There’s only one way to improve “Private Practice”: a Do Not Resuscitate order.

Well, decide for yourselves, guys! Private Practice premieres tonight on ABC, and you can bet I’m going to watch it. Well, I’m going to TIVO it…I have a girls night tonight, and a couple drinks sounds better than sitting and watching TV. But I’ll totally watch it tomorrow when the kids are at school.

Posted by:
Wednesday, September 26th, 2007 at 9:21pm
Filed under Kate Walsh | 14 Comments »

14 Responses to “Will Private Practice bomb?”

  1. ajays Says:

    I’m watching it right now and it’s actually better than I thought it would be.

  2. Carolyn Says:

    My hubby and I really liked it! Shonda Rhimes wrote the episode. I hope it lasts!

  3. Nelly Says:

    I didn’t really care for it. The story plot with the pregnant woman was too far out there and predictable that something was going to go seriously wrong. I also agree with the article that they are making Addison another Meredith Grey. I like tough Addison!

  4. T Says:

    She looks anorexic and 50 years old in that pic.

  5. Theresa Says:

    GAwd! That picture of her is horrible!!! The show was really predictable. Although I don’t watch Greys’s anymore, This was a letdown in the first episode.

  6. Pamela Says:

    Uh, i think she is a wee bit too old to be wearing that style of shirt… Saggy boobs in those tops is not attractive. This pic makes her look tranny-ish.

  7. katrina Says:

    Wow. That is a really bad picture of her. Her boobs are hanging pretty low!

  8. matty Says:

    It was terrible. I agree he aged. it was crappy and contrived. and it feels like theactng is bad ….

  9. Lesh Says:

    I have to agree with the reviewer, the show wasn’t good. I knew after watching the pilot it would be bad. I don’t think it will take too long for it to get cancelled.

  10. Ella Says:

    Man, I always thought Kate Walsh was unattractive, but that picture is awful! He chest, her hands, her face….that should be burned. I actually feel kinda sorry for her in that…

  11. Lor Says:

    UGLY, UGLY, UGLY, UGLY, UGLY, UGLY, UGLY, UGLY, UGLY.

  12. Dan Says:

    Raise boobs and airbrush those doggie style kneecaps. More frightening are the phalanges of her right hand. I wouldn’t hit it.

  13. Anonymous Says:

    I don’t understand how anyone could have expected this show to be any good, since spin-offs never live up to the originals and Grey’s is bad enough as it is.

  14. Oh girl Says:

    Yeah, the show may bomb if she doesn’t wear a bra in it. for sure..

Leave a Reply. May take a few minutes to appear.

You can Register for faster commenting!












Follow ICYDK



Angelina Jolie
Beyonce
Brad Pitt
Britney Spears
Cameron Diaz
Christina Aguilera
Jennifer Aniston
Jennifer Lopez
Jessica Simpson
Justin Timberlake
Kim Kardashian
Lady Gaga
Lindsay Lohan
Miley Cyrus
Rihanna
Robert Pattinson
Scarlett Johannson
Taylor Swift
Twilight
Victoria Beckham
ALL OTHERS...




ICYDK's Favorite Sites!

SPONSORS:


Fleetwood Mac Eagles tickets, Eric Clapton Jeff Beck tickets, Jay-Z tickets, Taylor Swift tickets, U2 tickets plus Bon Jovi tickets!