Private Practice actress leaves the show, gets replaced!
(I really can’t say I’m upset about it. I’ve never liked her)

Pointed questioning forced Grey’s Anatomy/Private Practice creator Shonda Rhimes to air her thoughts about the variety of dustups, large and small, that have continued to erupt around her blockbuster baby and its spinoff. On replacing Merrin Dungey — who already appeared as a main character in the Grey’s episode that served as Practice’s pilot — with Broadway star Audra Macdonald: ”I don’t think we can really go wrong with a four-time Tony winner.” On recent revelations that booted Grey’s star Isaiah Washington was in talks with rival net NBC before he got word that he was no longer welcome at Seattle Grace: ”I wasn’t aware of any conversation he had. But he’s a really talented actor, and I hope Bionic Woman does well — just not as well as Private Practice.” On the much-maligned George-and-Izzy coupling: ”I’m not necessarily saying George and Izzy are the love story of the century. People make mistakes and [their hookup] may or may not be one.” And, most importantly, of course, on the unnerving talking elevator in the Practice episode: ”I don’t know if it will be back.” (Thank God!!!)





July 27th, 2007 at 1:59 pm
I just didnt like this spin-off. Of course its new but I felt it didnt have the magic that Grey’s does. It felt so forced. But if they can tweak it a bit, maybe ill watch it.
August 11th, 2007 at 12:00 am
I liked Private Practice but thought it needed a lot of tweaking. I’m thrilled they replaced Merrin. Her performance was extremely flat and she had no chemistry w/ anyone on the show, in my opinion. I don’t know much about Audra MacDonald. However, in her picture, she looks a little older than the other actors on the show. I hope it doesn’t appear this way on camera.
September 9th, 2007 at 5:16 pm
I liked the spin-off and I liked Merrin. We went to high school together and she was great then and she’s still great. I will be watching. Can’t say that I’m sad to see the talking elevator disappear.